Business owners often spend years planning how their companies will grow, but far less time considering what will happen if an owner retires, becomes disabled, dies, or unexpectedly leaves the business.
Without a clear plan, the company and its remaining owners may face uncertainty at an already difficult time. Questions may arise about who will control the departing owner’s interest, how the business will be valued, and whether there is enough money available to complete a purchase.
A properly structured buy-sell agreement can provide a framework for addressing these situations and serve as an important part of a broader business-succession plan.
What Is a Buy-Sell Agreement?
Despite its name, a buy-sell agreement is not simply a contract to sell a business. It is a legally binding arrangement that establishes what will happen to an owner’s interest when certain events occur.
Depending on its terms, the agreement may require or permit the company, the remaining owners, or another designated buyer to purchase the departing owner’s interest.
The agreement can also limit an owner’s ability to transfer shares to an outside party. This helps the remaining owners maintain control over who may become an owner of the company.
What Events Can Trigger the Agreement?
A buy-sell agreement should identify the events that activate its provisions. These are commonly referred to as triggering events and may include:
- Death
- Long-term disability
- Retirement
- Voluntary departure
- Termination of employment
- Bankruptcy
- Divorce
- Loss of a required professional license
- A dispute or deadlock between owners
- An attempted transfer to an outside party
Different events may require different purchase terms. For example, the terms following an owner’s death may not be the same as those that apply when an owner voluntarily leaves to join a competitor.
Defining these situations in advance can reduce uncertainty and disagreement later.
Why Is an Agreement Important?
When an owner leaves without a buy-sell agreement, the remaining owners may unexpectedly find themselves in business with the former owner’s spouse, children, creditors, or another outside party.
The departing owner or family may also have difficulty converting the ownership interest into cash. The business may not have the resources to purchase it, and there may be no established method for determining a fair price.
A buy-sell agreement can help:
- Identify who may purchase the ownership interest
- Restrict transfers to unwanted outside parties
- Establish a valuation process
- Create a payment structure
- Provide liquidity to the departing owner or family
- Support continuity for employees and customers
- Reduce the possibility of disputes
- Clarify what happens during an unexpected event
While an agreement cannot eliminate every risk, it can provide a process when emotions and financial pressures may be high.
Who Will Purchase the Ownership Interest?
Buy-sell agreements can be structured in several ways. Two common arrangements are an entity purchase and a cross-purchase.
Entity-Purchase Arrangement
Under an entity-purchase arrangement, the business purchases the departing owner’s interest. This may also be referred to as a redemption arrangement.
This approach can be simpler when a company has several owners because the business may own any insurance policies used to fund the purchase.
Cross-Purchase Arrangement
Under a cross-purchase arrangement, the remaining owners purchase the departing owner’s interest directly.
This structure may have different tax, administrative, and insurance considerations, particularly when there are multiple owners.
Combination Arrangement
Some agreements provide flexibility by allowing either the company or the remaining owners to complete the purchase. The appropriate structure depends on the company, its ownership, tax considerations, and the objectives of the owners.
Legal and tax professionals should evaluate the alternatives before an agreement is adopted.
How Will the Business Be Valued?
A buy-sell agreement should clearly explain how the ownership interest will be valued. A fixed dollar amount written into an agreement can quickly become outdated as the company grows or conditions change.
Possible valuation methods may include:
- A value established and updated periodically by the owners
- A defined formula based on financial results
- An independent professional appraisal
- Multiple appraisals with a process for resolving differences
- A combination of methods
The agreement should also address whether discounts may apply to a minority ownership interest or to shares that cannot be freely sold. Because valuation provisions can have significant financial and tax consequences, they should be developed with qualified professionals.
How Will the Purchase Be Funded?
An agreement may establish an obligation to purchase an ownership interest, but the company or remaining owners must still have the financial ability to complete the transaction.
Potential funding sources include:
- Cash reserves
- Borrowing
- Installment payments
- Life insurance
- Disability insurance
- A combination of funding methods
Life insurance is commonly considered when death is a triggering event. The business or other owners may purchase policies on each owner’s life and use the proceeds to help fund the required purchase.
Disability-related transfers may present additional challenges because disability can be difficult to define and may last for an uncertain period. The agreement should coordinate with any disability insurance or disability buyout coverage.
Insurance does not replace a properly drafted agreement, and an agreement does not create funding on its own. The legal provisions and funding strategy should be reviewed together.
What Happens to the Owner’s Family?
When an owner dies, the family may inherit an interest in the company but have no role in running it. The family may need liquidity for living expenses, debts, taxes, or other financial goals.
A funded buy-sell agreement can create a process through which the family receives payment while ownership transfers to the company or remaining owners.
This arrangement may benefit both sides. The family does not have to become involved in a business it may not understand, and the remaining owners retain control of the company.
However, the agreement should be coordinated with the owner’s will, trusts, beneficiary designations, and broader estate plan. Conflicting documents can create delays and disputes.
An Agreement Should Not Be Placed on a Shelf
Businesses change over time. New owners may join, existing owners may leave, company value may increase, and insurance coverage may no longer match the expected purchase obligation.
A buy-sell agreement should be reviewed periodically and after major events, including:
- A significant change in business value
- A change in ownership
- Marriage or divorce
- A major change in an owner’s health
- The addition or loss of a key employee
- A change in business structure
- New tax or legal developments
- The purchase, replacement, or expiration of insurance coverage
An outdated agreement can create almost as much uncertainty as having no agreement at all.
Include the Agreement in the Broader Succession Plan
A buy-sell agreement addresses what happens to an ownership interest under specific circumstances. It does not, by itself, identify who will lead the company, prepare the next generation, or ensure that daily operations continue.
A complete succession plan should also address:
- Future leadership
- Emergency decision-making authority
- Management responsibilities
- Access to essential records and systems
- Communication with employees and customers
- The owner’s retirement-income needs
- Estate and tax planning
The agreement should work in coordination with these other elements.
Plan Before a Triggering Event Occurs
The best time to negotiate a buy-sell agreement is when the owners are working together and no triggering event is imminent. Waiting until an owner is ill, ready to retire, or involved in a dispute can make reaching an agreement far more difficult.
By establishing the terms in advance—and reviewing them regularly—business owners can create greater clarity for themselves, their families, their employees, and the future of the company.
This material is provided for general informational purposes and is not intended as legal, tax, accounting, insurance, valuation, or investment advice. Business owners should consult the appropriate professionals regarding their individual circumstances.
Discover more from FPA Owner Transitions
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
